
The case concerns Mazhar Mushtaq, a 35-year-old Pakistani national who is facing criminal proceedings in Malta arising from allegations dating back to 2018.
Mushtaq was charged with rape, forcing a minor to participate in pornography, engaging in sexual activity with a minor through violence, misuse of telecommunications equipment and the production of child pornography. The prosecution alleges that the offences involved a 15-year-old girl and the use of social media platforms including Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat. Mushtaq has pleaded not guilty to the charges.
The accused had previously been granted bail during the ongoing proceedings. After failing to attend court sittings, he left Malta and a European Arrest Warrant was subsequently issued in February 2023.
He was eventually located in Genoa, Italy, and returned to Malta to face the pending proceedings.
Application concerning breach of bail
Following his return, the prosecution, led by Inspector Marshal Mallia, filed an application in the original criminal proceedings informing the Court of the alleged breach of bail and requesting that his bail be revoked.
The defence team, comprising Dr Franco Debono, Dr Marion Camilleri and Dr Herman Mula, argued that the applicable legal provisions did not clearly establish the consequences that could follow from the procedure adopted by the prosecution.
Court identifies lacuna in the law
The case was decided by Magistrate Claire Stafrace Zammit, who examined the legal framework governing breaches of bail.
The Court noted that the law provides the prosecution with two possible avenues when dealing with an alleged breach of bail. It may submit an application within the existing criminal proceedings seeking the revocation of bail, or alternatively the accused may be brought before the Court under arrest for the alleged breach.
The Magistrate observed that the law expressly provides for certain consequences where an accused is arraigned under arrest, including the possibility of revoking bail or ordering the confiscation of the bail bond.
However, the legal position was less clear where the prosecution proceeded by means of an application filed within the original proceedings.
The Court consequently identified a lacuna in the law concerning the consequences of an alleged breach of bail in such circumstances.
Applying the principle that, where there is doubt, this should operate in favour of the accused, the Court declined to order Mushtaq’s rearrest.
The Magistrate also ordered that a copy of the ruling be forwarded to the Speaker of the House of Representatives, highlighting the legislative gap identified by the Court.
Dr Herman Mula of HM Advocates formed part of the defence team representing the accused in these proceedings.
The criminal allegations referred to above remain allegations, and the accused has pleaded not guilty. This article summarises publicly reported court proceedings and the decision concerning the alleged breach of bail.